Just for fun - who wears it better? ;)

[dieastra]

Just some quick fun ;)
Can you settle the fight for these guys? What's your opinion?

Comments

[spaciireth.livejournal.com]

I am not the biggest of Sherlock fans, but I would say his is the best coat. I prefer the length and that it has a bit more shape to it.

[alumfelga.livejournal.com]

All cool characters wear coats! :) I can't possibly choose one.

I love Sherlock's coat. I like the texture and it looks like it's warm, I could wear it on daily basis and it wouldn't feel like cosplay. It looks very good on Sherlock, with the collar up and the read lining bringing some new colour to his outfits.

Jack's coat looks heavy... It fits him but I can feel it's a costume and it's meant to look good in camera. I don't think you run comfortably in it :)

The Doctor's coat always makes me think about David Tennant's first words after he's been offered the role: Can I have a really long coat? This coat is so his. I don't think many people would pull it off, you have to be tall and skinny to look good in it.
Sometimes it looks weird when he wears the coat and his companion has much less layers. The most extreme case is Tooth and Claw when the Doctor wears a t-shirt, a shirt, a collar shirt, jacket and the coat, while "the naked child" Rose has only a t-shirt and an overall miniskirt. They had a long walk outside so either she was cold or he was hot. Someone didn't think it through.

[geekslave.livejournal.com]

I think Jack's my favorite, not just because he's my favorite out of those three, but when I think Jack inevitably I think of that coat. It definitely feels a part of his character.

I will say Sherlock's coat is the only one of those coats I would actually wear.

Stacey

[sandy79.livejournal.com]

1. Jacks Mantel - weil er sowohl zum Charakter als auch zu John selbst passt
2. Sherlock - gibt ihm den richtigen Hauch von "mysteriös" und hätte, so zum Drüberstreuen, die perfekte Länge für mich
3. Der Mantel des Doktors

[hamsterwoman]

I actually like the Doctor's coat, 'cos I prefer brown coats to any other color. And it looks the swishiest. But Sherlock'c coat is also very cool.

[merlynsminion.livejournal.com]

You need to do a poll!
Jack!

[dancingdragon3.livejournal.com]

Aw, don't throw things, but here I like Sherlock in his coat best, even though I want to say Ten. But in real life, I would probably say Jack, then Ten.

Hope your weekend's going well. I feel like I haven't spoken to you in a few days, but I've been unwell, and not keeping up with things like I usually do. I'll come back by tomoro when I've not been working all day. :-)

[jackwabbit.livejournal.com]

It's Sherlock by a mile for me.

[owensheart.livejournal.com]

Haha love this.

[colej55.livejournal.com]

I honestly can't choose. I adore them all on the characters who wore them. They are each signature pieces that helped define each person and I'd recognize the characters by seeing their coats alone. That's pretty special!

We are denied ticky boxes. :(

[heather mccrillis (from livejournal.com)]

Capt. Harkness', because it has had the most fun. I always think of Ten's suit before I think of his coat and Sherlock's wouldn't flap in the wind enough to double as a cape. :/